← Nonviolent communication examples

The refund runaround

Dropped the ball · A practice scene from lets-talk

You work the support desk. A customer has called three times about a refund, been passed between two teams, and been promised a callback that never came. Now they've reached you.

"This is the third time I'm explaining this. Do you even read the notes?"

Ask yourself: What has each transfer cost them, beyond the money?

Underneath

The refund is the small part now. Three calls, two teams and a missed callback taught them that nobody owns their problem. They need one person to say "I've got this" and mean it, with a time attached.

Pick a reply

Same sticky moment. Different landings.

"Please calm down. I can't help you if you shout at me."

Stings. Telling an angry person to calm down makes their anger the problem instead of the three calls. It usually hands them one more thing to be angry about.

Can trigger: Being told to calm down

"You're right, you shouldn't have to explain this again. I've read the notes: three calls, and a callback that never came. I'm keeping your case now, and I'll call you by 3 today with the refund date. Is this the best number?"

Door stays open. Names their exact complaint, owns the runaround, and gives them one owner, a time and a choice. That is what all the transfers took away.

"I'm sorry, but that was a different department. Our policy is 5 to 10 business days."

Stings. Policy and "a different department" are true and no use here. They hear one more person passing the problem along.

Can trigger: Passed along again

"I'm so sorry for the trouble. Let me transfer you to the refunds team, they'll sort it out."

Muddy. The apology is kind, but another hand-off undoes it. If you have to transfer, stay on the line and pass the notes on yourself.

Can trigger: Another transfer

A reply with all four parts

What happened
When you've called three times, been passed between teams, and the callback you were promised never came,
How you felt
I feel embarrassed and sorry
What you needed
because you shouldn't have to explain this a fourth time to get it sorted.
What you asked
I've read the notes and I'm keeping your case. Can I confirm the order number, then call you back by 3 p.m. today with the refund date?

Lines that make it worse

Read more

More from Dropped the ball