← Nonviolent communication examples

Holiday half-yes

Dropped the ball · A practice scene from lets-talk

In October your sister asked if you'd stay for the whole holiday week. You said "probably" to get off the phone. Now she's planned meals around you, and you can only do two days.

"I planned the whole week around you."

Ask yourself: What did "probably" sound like on her end of the phone?

Underneath

"Probably" was a no you didn't want to say. She heard a yes and planned on it. A clear answer now, with what you can do, beats another soft one that slips again.

Pick a reply

Same sticky moment. Different landings.

"I said probably, not yes."

Stings. Technically true, and it makes her the one who got it wrong. She planned on your word.

Can trigger: Feeling foolish for trusting you

"I'm sorry, "probably" was me avoiding a no. I can do Friday and Saturday, not the whole week. Can we plan those two days together now?"

Door stays open. Names the vague answer, gives a clear yes to what you can do, and makes the new plan hers too.

"Ugh, fine. I'll figure it out." (You can't.)

Stings. A second vague yes sets up the same letdown later, and the sigh tells her you'll resent it.

Can trigger: Another plan that falls through

"Let me check my schedule and get back to you."

Muddy. Fair if you truly don't know, but it's the same move as "probably." Give her a day when she'll have the answer.

Can trigger: More waiting

A reply with all four parts

What happened
When I said "probably" about the holiday week and never told you more,
How you felt
I feel guilty and a bit awkward
What you needed
— you deserved a straight answer while you were still planning.
What you asked
I can come Friday and Saturday. Can we plan those two days together now?

Lines that make it worse

Read more

More from Dropped the ball